Open Question: What Zodiac Signs Are Overrated? Who Is Underrated?

December 12th, 2011 @ 8:36 am by Elsa

Ask the collective

zodiac boxjoana writes:

“…Scorpios are definitely overrated, just as Virgos are underrated.”

I agree that Virgo is underrated as is Capricorn. Pisces is rarely valued outside of being a sex toy for Scorpio so I would call them underrated as well. I can’t see that any of the signs are overrated. You?

Is there are sign you feel is given more credit than they deserve? How about a sign that is undervalued?

Send a question to “Ask the collective”



advertisement below

42 Responses to “Open Question: What Zodiac Signs Are Overrated? Who Is Underrated?”

1.
max
max

I agree that Virgo is underrated as is Capricorn.

I dunno; I could maybe see Capricorn as underrated, but Virgos are very very humble and let you know it at least five times a day, usually ten. (And I have lots of Virgo in my chart, ya know.)

Pisces is rarely valued outside of being a sex toy for Scorpio

I’ve never had the occasion to use Pisces as a sex toy; the women are too sweet to do that to.

The only sign that I could see as particularly over- or under-valued would be Aquarius. What you hear (in astrological circles, which is where it counts) is that Aquarius is the future, we should all aspire to be Aquarius and put Aquarius in charge of every thing so our cloned, foodpill-eating, hermaphodite Brave New World future where everyone is identically happy doing indentical things can get here faster.

max
['I think that's an Uranian-envy thing tho.']

 
2.
Diana
Diana

I feel that Virgos are definitely underrated, especially when it comes to sexuality. The way I see it is that they participate in sexual acts which they find immoral only when others take pleasure from them. I don’t consider that very humble.

Capricorns are underrated as well, people forget how elegant and graceful this sign is. I am not particularly fond of them, but I don’t pin them down as boring or monotone as many people do. They just aren’t as intense as Scorpios.

I feel very immune to Scorpio manipulation because I can detect manipulation quite easily, so for that I find that they are overrated. However, their psychology of things is almost always spot on just as Pisces’ intuition never seems to fail.

I think every single sign is overrated and underrated in one way or another.

I also don’t find Aquarius’ to be weird in any way, they don’t surprise me like they seem to surprise other people.

 
3.
Ana
Ana

Capricorn is definitely underrated, but so is Aries and Gemini! Geminis the world over, unite :)

 
4.
Twilight
Twilight

I agree about Virgo and Capricorn – Taurus too – all the Earth signs seem to lack glamour if you look at it from a purely Sun sign point of view, even though Taurus is ruled by Venus, it’s still not really thought of a sign to envy.

It’s lucky that we all (or most of us) have bits of many signs within our makeup. Those Earthy Suns, often thought of as being a bit pedantic or square usually have close personal planets nextdoor or 2 doors down to spice ‘em up a bit. :-)

 
5.
kharma09
kharma09

I believe that Libras are underrated. They always seem to describe us as so easy going and middle of the road, partner oriented. The other air signs like Gemini are called dynamic and Aquarius as progressively unique. Books don’t seem to repeat the “needy” partner slant regarding them as they do Libras. I for one like to believe that I’m my own person irregardless of a partner. True, I did use to be highly codependent – lol. Sun, Venus, Uranus in Libra 11th house. Capricorn Moon 2nd :)

 
6.
Viv
Viv

Pisces are usually only valued for being sex toys for scorpio? wow. I find that offensive. I’ve never heard it before.

I think pisces are much more in control then people may think, they’re in as much control as they want to be.
They know much more then they let on. and it’s not intentional/manipulative. maybe that’s the only thing we can’t control. Pisces have different priorities then most people.
I don’t lik people having pitty for pisces. we’re victims of ourselves at most.

Capricorn is underrated, they have infinite potential as human beings.

 
7.
Gem
Gem

I think they are all about equal. Many of my friends are virgos and caps and pretty freakin’ full of themselves. Esp the virgo gals I know…so it’s all mixed up to me. I still love them. It’s entertaining.

-leo in the house

 
8.
Rhonda
Rhonda

How about this. I have capricorn sun, pisces rising & taurus moon and I feel completely underrated in most every circle of people. I wish for Leo flair or Libra balance and beauty. I still stick my neck our there and try to make a difference in my community by volunteering on committees and spending time at my daughter’s school. I don’t have the nicest car or clothes, but my life is about serving my family and giving of myself, so while I always feel like everyone is looking at my flaws (which I tend to obsess over) My pisces asc. picks up on all those “Joneses” moms’ feelings about me, so I know which ones are two-faced, but I treat them all kindly and wish them peace, it’s the way of the tao.

 
9.
andro
andro

max- aquarius would love that only in theory- they don’t want to be the same as anybody. :-)

I agree that virgo is underrated. Not necessarily by virgoes themsevles- at least not the ones that follow some astrology, but by a more general audience. I can almost hear people’s thoughts when I say “I’m a virgo.” they say “hmmm” but the look I get is “BORING!!!! BORING ALERT!!! RUN FOR THE HILLS WHERE THE REAL PEOPLE ARE!!!”

I think part of the problem is, a lot of people just don’t want to think.

 
10.
casey31652
casey31652

Personally, I have never known an Aries who was underrated. How on earth can you underrate all that fire energy? I also don’t believe Scorpios are overrated. I think most people are TERRIFIED of Scorpios.

I agree, however, that capable, quiet Capricorn is underrated — especially their sense of humor. Which is droll and dry.

And most people write Pisces off as alcholic, drug-dependent whiney babies. So yes, I think we’re underrated.

 
11.
dreamsAreality
dreamsAreality

I don’t think we hear enough about that good old Libra balance. A smoother LESS DRAMA-FIED life -yes – some adventure, granted – some staid.

Thus, not as many shock-absorber replacements needed.

 
12.
mychar
mychar

I think virgos and pisces are underrated. Virgos aer very passionate, but they are very particular with whom to reveal their emotions. Pisces know/sense quite a bit but they don’t flaunt it, they are very humble. Capricorns are full of themselves, too condescending.

 
13.
wyrdling
wyrdling

i don’t underrate capricorn. they have a knack for getting things done. though they drive me nuts when they don’t take me seriously for whatever reason ;)

i’ve long felt virgo was underrated. but virgo seems to prefer it that way. i don’t go around telling people how humble i am, but i don’t think i’m all that humble, i’m just not comfortable tooting my own horn.

and i adore pisces. (course, that could be the 7th house talking) don’t think they’re underrated at all, just some people don’t appreciate what they are.

and i think scorpios are misunderstood, in exactly the way they want to be, most of the time. not overrated, exactly. there’s a mystique, and i think to a point it’s designed to keep people from looking at the parts of themselves they want to keep hidden.

if anyone’s underrated, i think it might be taurus.

 
14.
Shannon
Shannon

I think that its funny the way people view a piesces being one myself. Sex toys? Ill take that as a compliment. I think that piesces are underrated in a sense that people dont realize how complex we truely are. I myself feel mis understood by many signs. I have also felt that people do view us as weak indiviguals, when we are far from that. We may be sensitive, but we can still take whatever is thrown our way.

 
15.
Sandy
Sandy

i def think caps are underrated. they are actually very passionate people, but they hide it well with their serious demeanors. i think virgo women are great and definitely underrated. they can be quite ambitious and full of life. i don’t find virgo men to be similar in that regard, though. they are pretty drab. i don’t think pisces are underrated. the problem with them is that they’re not good at using their gifts to reach their full potential. they are apathetic in a sense, and that’s never a good thing, and it can be quite frustrating for those who are more ambitious and tenacious. as for scorps, i think that they are greatly misunderstood. the best way to describe them is that they have great powers and can use them either for good or evil. those scorps who use them for good can be some of the most caring, determined, and successful people on the planet. those who get stuck in the negativity of life and use their powers for bad do exist but they are not as common as the former. so no, they aren’t overrated. either way you slice it, they are the embodiment of power…and that’s pretty damn powerful.

 
16.
von
von

I am seriously laughing out loud at “Pisces is rarely valued outside of being a sex toy for Scorpio”… I have two such Scorpios who have been in and out of my life and my body for the last 4 years LMAO

 
17.
sonah22
sonah22

No one even talks about CANCER. We’re like the invisible sign. I can’t wait until next month so I can actually read about us more. Cancer wins this hands down!

Now I’m going to go eat a bag of chips and cry.

 
18.
Elsa
Elsa

sonah22 – LMAO!

 
19.
Luci
Luci

I think Leos are underrated. Let’s hear more about them. *big, cheesy grin*

What? I’m not a Leo. I’m a Pisces….with a Leo moon!

 
20.
Luci
Luci

And yes, that was my attempt at humor. :D

 
21.
persian_cat
persian_cat

Underrated? That word is not in my book. Sun conj Asc in Leo. Rarrrr!

 
22.
DontRepYourCity
DontRepYourCity

Overrated: Fire/Water signs
Underrated: Air/Earth signs

Just calling it like I see it…

 
23.
Elsa
Elsa

Welcome, Don’tRep. :)

 
24.
blackjack
blackjack

I think cancer is the most underrated star sign. Emotional, clingy, moody, needy, gets the leftovers, jealous, possessive and basically all the traits that no one wants or has. I mean what good traits do we possess anyways. Friend in need, listener, caretaker, emotional trash can. We must be the most boring people on earth. lol
Most overrated probably has to be scorpio and libra. From the threads I’ve seen-sexually magnetic , charming sociable etc.

 
25.
Elsa
Elsa

Welcome, blackjack. :)

 
26.
GoldenVirgo
GoldenVirgo

in astrology descriptions on websites, they typically make virgos sound like the most boring, annoying people on earth. and they verbally fellate aquarius. i’m surprised aquarians don’t all have diabetes from the thick sugar coating astrology sites lay on them.

however in daily life, i find that pisces are usually underrated by people the most. the mysticism of how they are isn’t obvious enough for most people to give them the credit they’re due. once again, in daily life, aquarians win the overrated award again, unfortunately. IME, they have 800 friends, and they do whatever necessary to keep the flock pleased with their image. if the aquarian must lie, or pretend to be something they’re not to fit in, then so be it. doesn’t sound too original to me. nor do i understand the strong desire to associate with such a fake person, idc HOW funny they are.

 
27.
Elsa
Elsa

Welcome, GoldenVirgo. ;)

 
28.
Conoco
Conoco

Cancer is a definite winner in my book! I mean, without that mothering energy, there’d be no way you get along with your mother, LOL!

 
29.
barb
barb

Definitely Pisces! I always feel honoured to meet a kind Pisces…they’re usually riding under the radar somewhere.

 
30.
catfishmass
catfishmass

I’m not sure if it’s underrated or maligned, but I second blackjack’s older post about Cancer. I always feel like I have to defend being a Cancer sun, like no I’m not weepy or needy, gah.

 
31.
Isernia
Isernia

Max – As an Aquarian ASC, LOL!! Not quite the future I am looking for. I am, however, eagerly awaiting the day food replicators are finally invented.

I have to agree Cancer is underrated. My Aries son has a Cancer ASC. Cancer can be a big pot of trouble if it’s not handled properly. Too much is never enough. It’s all about his feeeelings.

With four planets in Pisces, I agree with the Scorpio sex toy statement. That is exactly how the Scorpio ex treated me – like an inanimate object for his pleasure only. Bah!

 
32.
Darknight
Darknight

Ares are over rated. They are the children of the zodiac.
Scorpio overrates themselves.
Libras (as well as ALL air) are wisps on the willow.
Capricorns are underrated. And we like it like that.
Virgos? I see virgos as miss represented. You see, they wish they were scorpios. But any old scorpio can be a ho. Virgos just turn it into a business. That takes smarts that scorpios just don’t have.

 
33.
Caroline
Caroline

Yes, Capricorn is underrated!

 
34.
music4am
music4am

I think leo is definitely overrated and would agree that cappy is underrated,
Angie

 
35.
lalola
lalola

Yes definitly virgo ,, I belive we are very complex layred individuals .. I won’t say I like to be a scorpio although I feel great resmblence with scorps like no other sign

Leo are overrated .. I mean I can’t get how irrogance for example is a great trait? Almost all leo are full of them self I honestly can’t get it.. And the bravery leader thing also follows I just can’t “digest” this sign ! Not all leo of course are like that ..

& here on board you don’t feel cap are underrated the real sign many complain about having as rising for ex is poor virgo as if its a curse of some kind …

 
36.
Blessed Place
Blessed Place

Virgo, Cancer and Taurus are underrated but that’s largely because so few fit the usual description (in my experience anyway). I agree the Earth signs are pretty misunderstood.

From my own pov Scorpio is very oeverrated – most I’ve known are kind of pantomime villains who play up the Scorp reputation without the substance to back it up. I’ve only known a handful of truly evolved Scorps –

but that might be true of most signs I guess

 
37.
McKenna
McKenna

a ha ha ha! Sex toys for Scorpio?

Yep, & it’s a one stop shop!

*grin*

 
38.
MJ
MJ

I will agree with all the Cancer answers. It’s not all about the signs. I am trilingual, Chilean, Canadian raised in Switzerland… To say that i am defined by my sun sign Cancer throws people off. I am sensitive, but strong. I quite like my creative mind and love to fantasize about ALL things but I am grounded and know how to work hard, play hard (perhaps the Taurus in me. I don’t even read my horoscope anymore, it’s about your soul and your light.

I have many Scorpios in my life and I love them, emotional, fiery, kind, fun, a little too much EGO though… they get such a bad rep with the sexual aspect of the sign, us Cancers can be just as naughty, just saying.

I’m starting to see more of the downs of Aries, I can identify that they can be quite selfish, though quite sexy..

That’s my story and I’m sticking to it (Taurus again! lol)

 
39.
Elsa
Elsa

Welcome, MJ. :)

 
40.
queenfluff
queenfluff

Virgo Sun here – and yes, I feel underrated -but I would rephrase that to overlooked – I think Virgos are often not seen – eveyone expects the Virgo to do all the work so they can be lazy. True we like to work and we are good at it ..but no more people taking advantage of me because I am TOO NICE!!! Us Virgo needs to be more selfish if you ask me. We are definately not appreciated by many people. Also we are NOT prudes and most of us do not dress like librarians! Most people would never guess I am a Virgo.

That said – my Rising sign is Scorpio – I have really no interest in sex – all this stuff about Scorpios being sex fiends – not true! – I think it is better to say Scorpios are misunderstood – too many Scorpios (and Virgo) stereotypes exist – Having a lot of Scorpio myself (sun conjunct pluto exact) I can say that being a Scorpio type is NOT easy at all! The only people that really get me are other Scorpios (usually Suns) and Cancers. We are emotional more than anything else. We DO have the sexiness down but just so you know most of us don’t even know we are doing it! So give us a break on that one! :)

I do think that Capricorns are probably also given a bad rap because of Saturn (but I don’t like Saturn either but I don’t think that means that Capricorns are like a bad Saturn) – but for the most part I can’t really give any evidence – my brother is a Capricorn and yeah, he is a typical one except the work stuff but he hoards the money he has and is a loner. I would say the Capricorns of the world probably do work too much but at least, they aren’t the lazy ones of the zodiac and accomplish something (probably one of the first signs to appreciate the Virgo!)

I hate to say this but I get tired of hearing how Libras are supposed to be the most attractive sign in the zodiac – I don’t believe it. My last two ex’s were both Libra (one had Libra rising and sun in 1st too) and I am better looking than both of them. I think Libras are overrated on that there. I also would call them selfish and stubborn. It might just have been the Libras I know – but they can’t admit they are wrong or have made a mistake. I don’t think they are balanced at all – at least the ones I knew were not and libras are supposed to be known for being balanced.

As a Virgo, I think Geminis are overrated – mostly because I don’t like sharing a planet with them because I don’t think they make good use of the Mercurial energy as they could – I think Virgos make better use of it. I am still waiting to get my own planet so I don’t have to share it with wishy washy Gemini.:) Than again, I don’t understand the air signs and all that “social” energy where people can’t sit still and “flit about” all over the place – being a moody Scorpio type myself – I don’t get it.

 
41.
D
D

Libras.

Two words.

Over rated.

Typo intended.

 
42.
beth
beth

old conversation! But my two cents:

Pisces. They’re often portrayed as pretty but ditzy.

Cancer

Capricorn- not underestimated so much as misunderstood.

I don’t think virgo is underestimated so much as largely ignored. Don’t tell virgos that, most have enough self-righteous humility already.

Most overestimated is Aquarius. They’re awesome but overhyped.

 


Get A Consultation

 

Thanks, we look forward to working with you! :-)  - Elsa P

 
 

Order a Report

Heads Up from Elsa P!

Sign up below to get my free weekly email newsletter covering the astrology of the next week. I send this email out every Thursday.

 

More


 
 

Recent Blog Comments

  • Elsa: Thank you, Deglet. :)
  • Deglet: Thank you for the consistently brilliant posts! You are at the t...
  • serena009: I love this article. I have Jup-Sat opposition in my SR and it'...
  • Jennifer: Another great post, Elsa. :) <3
  • morgan: Astrology correction :) Saturn return. 2nd house. No value for s...
  • morgan: I can relate to this. I've cut off people who have drained the e...
  • Peace Be With You: Jupiter has been opposing Saturn quite a bit in the last one yea...