What is Primal Between Men and Women vs What Might Evolve?

September 5th, 2011 @ 6:24 am by Elsa

Ask the collective

china bound feetFrom 2007 – t-carat writes in regards to the soldier’s asserting that men act differently when women are around as opposed to when they are by themselves:

“They don’t want to get into a crummy fort, they want to get into where the decisions that affect the world are made and where the money is.

If a man can’t work and be himself where women are he’s been living in a cave for the last 2-3 decades…”


t-carat – in soldier’s case it’s been a lot longer that 3 decades he’s been living in a cave. Try many, many lifetimes, but here’s the thing:

I am not sure that relationship between men and women has actually evolved… or that it even can evolve. Women binding their feet years ago in China, did so to attract a man. These days they get breast implants and shoot their faces full of botox and I don’t see the difference. A woman gets money and power and her crotch still aches for a man.

Looking around in 2007, it may appear things have changed, but have they really? From the soldier’s (historical) perspective they have not changed at all. Estrogen is estrogen and testosterone, testosterone. We can dress it up in various ways but does that actually alter anything beneath the surface?

Do you think the interaction between men and women is primal / hard wired or do you think it’s on the move?



advertisement below

21 Responses to “What is Primal Between Men and Women vs What Might Evolve?”

1.
Rhonda
Rhonda

I can’t obviously speak for others but for me, I’m beyond the primal urges. I don’t have much of a sex drive (37 years old) and maybe its endocrine related, but I can do without for extended periods of time. My husband is ALL MALE. When he gets home from his job on a gas rig after 2 weeks, he’s still cussing, talking about sports and going to the gym within 24 hours. While this is some of what endears me to him (he’s quite handsome and sexy) I’m over it. So I’m more “on the move” about man stuff cause by the time he goes back to work, I’m glad I don’t have to get laid every day and I don’t have to hear sportcenter 24-7. If we didn’t have a child I would have given up years ago and become a spinster!!!

 
2.
Piya
Piya

Well I don’t know because I like having sex a whole lot and I do try to look good so I can keep having it.

Thing is, no matter how many strides women make in the workplace, men are always going to act differently around a woman and women are always going to act differently around a man. I think men are more aware of the difference in the way they act.

I think this is just how men are. Acting differently doesn’t mean that they’re putting on an act around women. It doesn’t mean they’re putting on an act around men, either. You could say they’re adapting to the environment and I do this too. I have felt more myself around a lover than I have anywhere else … and who’s to say any man isn’t going to feel the same way?

 
3.
CD
CD

I think t-carat’s point (or at least what I got out of it) was not that women and men aren’t different, but that this difference shouldn’t be structurally interpreted in ways that are unequal.

So, men can be men in whatever way that means to them, but in the public arena it should be more neutral. Equal pay for equal work, that sort of thing. Because, the way it has been traditionally done, the structure benefits the old boy network (that’s not news to anyone of course). As long as men being men means I get the same pay and say, I could care less. Measure each other’s dicks, smash beer cans on your foreheads, whatever…

 
4.
Piya
Piya

CD, totally.

 
5.
Amethyst
Amethyst

Some people make a bigger issue out of gender than other people. I think a lot of it has to do with the way we are raised. I totally agree with CD.

 
6.
Elsa
Elsa

>>>I think a lot of it has to do with the way we are raised.>>>

Amethyst – I’m thinking you’re right about that…

 
7.
kashmiri
kashmiri

As I understand it, the Soldier is talking about underlying currents that run between the genders, and I agree with him. I also agree with the idea CD puts forward about the necessity of neutrality in the public arena.

I am much more comfortable these days about admitting the genders are so different…that’s an idea that really disturbed me when I was younger, especially as my feminist philosophy wasn’t fully formed. I simply lacked the life experience for it to be.

I am definately affected by the fact I grew up in a large, all-female family (even the family pet was female), and even more affected that my mum had suffered from sexual abuse and hadn’t received any help…and she was religious, so there were many messages about ‘How Men Are’ and ‘How Women Are’ and how we aren’t supposed to mix, men can’t be trusted, etc.
The irony of this is that my Dad is the most upstanding person you could ever meet in your life. A wonderful man, the finest example of a man or human being. He also warned us how horrible men were–even though he wasn’t. Huh?

Furthermore, I have been working in a pre-dominantly male workplace for over 5 years. Until very recently I was oblivious to this. I’d feel it every now and then, go for drinks after work, and a few beers in my Aries Mars would smell danger and I’d leave…what kind of danger? Not the kind my mum warned me about, but something like this:

We really are fucking different. And no, I don’t like being the only gal in the room sometimes…even with my guy friends. I am okay with men flirting with me, but I certainly want to know what my sexual energy is and how it is being directed. My life and my relationships with men have benefitted greatly by becoming more aware of these things.

 
8.
Ana
Ana

right on CD!

“men are always going to act differently around a woman and women are always going to act differently around a man” yes, that’s just the way it is. I know I act different around guys than I do when I’m with my female friends or by myself. Sexual energy changes the whole equation. Some people I think are more sensitive to this than others, and respond more to its presence.

Kashmiri – I love being the only woman in a group of men. I get so much energy just from being around them! Even when we don’t get along, it gives me a real buzz.

 
9.
Ana
Ana

t-carat – who says women don’t want to get in “where the decisions that affect the world are made and where the money is”?

Women love power. It gives them a position of safety and strength, it is a true equalizer. Women love power for the safety it creates, but men love power because it gets women! For him it is a means to get sex and love, for her it is way to avoid getting abused. The men who make the “decisions” and have all the money…there is always a woman they seek to impress. Take her away, and the incentive to go be successful shrinks considerably. Women, on the other hand, use power as a means to shield themselves from domination and abuse. Women have many forms of power in addition to the ones men have. Men no better than to screw over the woman who makes the decisions and signs their paycheck – and the one that loves them and has the babies. She is to be respected.

 
10.
Little Miss Hermit
Little Miss Hermit

http://news.yahoo.com/s/livescience/20071018/sc_livescience/feministshavemorefun

Some are raised more equal than others, and apparently, it doesn’t hurt:)

 
11.
Z
Z

I think there was a point when things started to change and that was probably at the start of the feminist movement. I see changes in the younger generations, men are alot less chauvinistic than they used to be, esp those brought up by strong women. The old boys network still exists though and still recruiting but many men see those kind of men for the misogynists they are. The same for old school women who put down other women’s hard climb up the ladder from subservience while pampering to the fragile male ego. And its not just women having botox and changing their bods..plenty of men are now as insecure about their looks, thats more about vanity and wanting to look ever youthful and perfect no? A media driven campaign to get us spending more money for the so called perfect life.

 
12.
Kathy
Kathy

Earlier you did a blog about “metrosexual” men – and that brought up the same feelings for me. I think women have always been willing to do whatever it takes to attract a man – hardwired – because men have always been women’s security. Now that the woman can make more money than her man, men are starting to feel less “manly” – and less impetus to be manly – thus the metrosexual trend. If a place away from women gives a man a shot of “macho”, I think his woman benefits from that the same as a woman benefits fom having “chick chats” with her friends. Even if you are interested in the same things, it’s good for a person to have friends outside the relationship. It keeps things fresh. I don’t think this negates the need for equality in work/pay/power. It just adds another dimension to life that’s missing in modern society.

 
13.
CD
CD

I wanted to add in case things don’t come across the way I want them to – I’m not saying the soldier is a good old boy or keeping women down or anything. Just that from a public standpoint, keeping women out has historically had real-world consequences beyond the personal comfort of those involved. I don’t think he approves of those consequences or anything.

 
14.
daisy
daisy

Bottom line men and women are hard wired. I grew up in a house and neighborhood where men where automatically smarter and always right no matter what. When I was young I waitressed in a truck stop, of course the male drivers had an opinion of the *girls.* This was not enough for me and it was frustrating, I wanted to drive one of them, I wanted to see the country, I wanted out there. I have Sag and merc in house 10. I got my commercial drivers license and I drove truck cross country for five years and let me tell you the entire mindset changed. I was no longer one of the *girls* I had earned the respect that over the road drivers had for each other. I was amazed at the difference in which I was treated. After I moved to Iowa and again I was amazed and impressed with how women where were treated, yes they where expected to perform more traditional home and child care roles, but when it came time to work the farm, they worked side by side with their man and they where respected and treated like anyone other person. Where I grew up a woman was never to set foot in a truck, or operate a combine, or own a chain saw, or split firewood. Yes women who can work side by side with a man does command respect even from the manliest man. So I agree men and women are hard wired at the most basic level, but as human’s with brains we don’t have to be just primal. We can be primal in private with the right person, but in public we can give and earn respect.
Sex is sex, respect is earned! And we are all capable of giving it and receiving it regardless of what body part is attached.

 
15.
mahchi
mahchi

silly me, put my comment in the wrong place :(

 
16.
Caroline
Caroline

I think it’s the same as it ever was, and now that I’ve caught on, I am faring much better in my mind and in my interactions with men.

 
17.
dorchid
dorchid

I think there are hard-wired differences. Certainly not enough to justify gender-based social inequalities. But enough to question our presumptions regarding relationships and sexuality. For example female mice who live alone are more prone to stress vs male mice who live alone. And male mice suffer more anxiety when rooming with a more dominant male vs female mice in similar situation.

 
18.
dorchid
dorchid

and that is one gnarly foot!

 
19.
eva
eva

I don’t know, I might be different or possibly too old to answer, but there’s also a life-cycle involvement. I guess I wanted a man when I was in my thirties but now maybe not.

Hormonally men and women lose interest in this stuff as they age. I’m not saying we all become these sexless husks — it’s still nice to feel pretty and fun to get a little attention once in a while but there’s just not that burning biological imperative in either gender. With the eighth house now I’m more concerned about money and dying.

So for a big part of the lifecycle — the fertile one — it’s huge. But pre-menstrually and post-menstrually…maybe not.

 
21.
julianwinter
 


Get A Consultation

 

Thanks, we look forward to working with you! :-)  - Elsa P

 
 

Order a Report

Heads Up from Elsa P!

Sign up below to get my free weekly email newsletter covering the astrology of the next week. I send this email out every Thursday.

 

More


 
 

Recent Blog Comments

  • serena009: I love this article. I have Jup-Sat opposition in my SR and it'...
  • Jennifer: Another great post, Elsa. :) <3
  • morgan: Astrology correction :) Saturn return. 2nd house. No value for s...
  • morgan: I can relate to this. I've cut off people who have drained the e...
  • Peace Be With You: Jupiter has been opposing Saturn quite a bit in the last one yea...
  • debdeb: Amazing.
  • daisy: I have a jupiter sun and a saturn moon. I have mastered bullet #...