Ask The Collective: Are Marriages (And Our Lives) Predestined?
Ask the collective…
A reader from India asks:
I just want to know that, are marriages really made in heaven? Is it fixed from before who is going to marry whom astrologically or some times marriages can be made and broken by human choices?
And is it possible that a girl A is “made” for a boy B, but somehow ends up in marrying another boy C?
And if this is possible then what will happen to the girl who was going to get married to the boy C??
I don’t think our lives are predestined. We’re constantly presented with choices and the choices we make lead to other sets of choices and so on.
In the example you present, I would say girl A is not made for either boy. She may be better suited to boy B, but if she marries boy C, the world is not going to collapse. In fact, she may wind up with Boy B, further down the road after other things fall into or out of place. We just don’t know the future!
I think the universe is dynamic and the plan, grand. I also have a very hard time believing one person’s bad choice will mess up another person’s life… over the long term.
In other words, you may think someone has wrecked your life but I think most people realize eventually, the things that have happened to them have served them in some way and research bears this out. Because most everyone, when asked if they would trade their life for the life of some other another person, say no.
What do the rest of you think about Girl A and her two boys?
24 Responses to “Ask The Collective: Are Marriages (And Our Lives) Predestined?”
I might have misspoke. What I meant to say was people, if you ask them if they would like to be someone else… have another person’s problems, they say no. As much as they may hate it, they want their own life. This is different than having regrets over choices they made. I think a lot of people have regrets…
Holy Elsa, that was a fast response!
I totally get what you’re saying. I used to say “I have no regrets” but it gets harder to say that the older you get, especially once you’ve made amends with people.
And hell no, I don’t want anyone else’s problems. I do want my own life.
I think about ‘lost loves’ too. The man my Mom pined for for YEARS before she met my Dad was revealed to be a child abuser. She’s pretty happy she didn’t sng him, afterall.
Hi Elsa
Your answer was very wise. I agree.
I think the idea that one person is “made for another” is a fanciful and romantic proposition which needs to be approached with suspicion. It might be nice if it were true though – and we could all find our elusive “only one”!
It’s often possible to say that a couple were “made for each other”, but usually only after they’ve spent many years working on it. It’s something that can be seen only with hindsight, I think.
“In other words, you may think someone has wrecked your life but I think most people realize eventually, the things that have happened to them have served them in some way and research bears this out.”
Sorry, I don’t believe this at all. It’s easy for us in the developed world to think this way. But what about someone who has been sold into white slavery and lives the rest of her life as a prostituted slave? The people who sold her into that life have most certainly wrecked her life and I doubt very much that when she is 70 she will feel as if everything happened “for a reason”. Or the 8 year old boy in Africa who is forced into being a soldier and committing unspeakable acts? Those kinds of things still happen in the world in this day and age. Some horrible things happen to people and they don’t always serve them in any way, nor are people always able to transform these experiences into something better. Terrible acts of heartbreak and betrayal happen every day and they’re not always correctible, if there is such a word.
Marly presupposes that the natural position for growth is comfort. I’ve had tragic things in my life that I wouldn’t trade for anything. I’ve also had bliss that didn’t lead anywhere.
I think it’s all about choices, forks in our little roads. Some people are placed in our life for a reason, whether it’s personal growth or comfort or whatever. These people are stepping stones in our personal evolution. Doesn’t make Boy A anymore valid for Girl A than Boy B, just gives them a different option and reasons to appear (and possibly disappear) in her life.
I think destiny is malleable as much an oxymoron that is. But it’s all about choices.
i think some types of people might be more compatible with each other (“made for each other”) than others, but i don’t think there is one and only one person who is “The One.” and people are never (or very rarely) going to be “perfectly” compatible with each other, though some relationships are probably easier to maintain than others, based on the people invovled.
so i guess it comes down to whether the amount of work you have to put in is worth it to you.
Are our lives predestined? Yes, I think that that is one of the fundamental principles of astrology in general. I tend to think that it is only our conditioning as modern people that live in a humanistic society that really leads us to reject this notion of predestination, even though it is one of the basic principles that we base our astrology on and the astrology itself seems to intimate that this is indeed the case. Of course this statement needs to be qualified, but still…
I tend to think that it is only our conditioning as modern people that live in a humanistic society that really leads us to reject this notion of predestination, even though it is one of the basic principles that we base our astrology on and the astrology itself seems to intimate that this is indeed the case.
Depends which kind of astrology, though, doesn’t it? I am quite fond of the free-will-psychological-astrology school myself but then again that’s not particularly predictive and I’ve never experiemented with how accurate astrological prediction is.
I just want to know that, are marriages really made in heaven?
More like purgatory. 
Is it fixed from before who is going to marry whom astrologically or some times marriages can be made and broken by human choices?
And is it possible that a girl A is “made” for a boy B, but somehow ends up in marrying another boy C?
I know that in India all these ideas are quite powerful because marriage is very important, as is marrying the right person, as is having astrological compatibility between the charts.
As a Western astrologer I have a fundamentally different view, which is all about free will and free choice.
As for destiny – I’ll give you a personal example. I grew up with two clairvoyants (people who have visions of the future) and they proved remarkably adept at predicting events years in advance (For instance they told my mother -who thought it was nonsense- about my father – and all kinds of random series of circumstances conspired to bring her to that meeting point). They also told my mother she was pregnant (me!) when all the tests in the hospital said she wasn’t and so on. Sometimes remarkable things happen to us (and seem destined to do so) – but the crux is this – they are neither necessarily comfortable nor pleasant.
My mother and I have a very strained relationship and have to work very hard on it. My mother and father felt themselves to be soulmates and loved each other deeply and passionately and intensely but their marriage was not a happy one. They hurt each other, and let each other down, although they also fundamentally remained friends and had a hard time letting each other go. On the other hand the man my mother got together with after my father died was someone she had known since her early 20s and with whom she had always considered herself incompatible with – but after the stormy relationship with my father she realised he was exactly what he wanted and they are very happy together eve now, eleven years on.
My point is – I think the biggest mistake people make is to assume that just because you recognise someone as a soulmate, or think it’s destiny, that that’s a good thing. Love is only the beginning. It still has to be filtered through the flawed and cracked lens of our own beliefs and expectations and damages and behaviour.
It is not enough to have destiny, and even if something is ‘destiny’ it doesn’t mean that is forever. Sometimes your destiny if you want to call it that is about meeting someone who helps you make a turning point (as Elsa’s saga of the special forces soldier is a testament to) and letting each other go.
Also I don’t think there’s a perfect compatibility chart. Two people might look perfect astrologically, but if they meet they’ll have no spark because you need a bit of squares/oppositions a bit of tension and energy to keep things going. With any relationship, any marriage, any cohabitations there are challenges. Also, people live out their natal charts in different ways so there’s no guarantee that Boy B would be in any way a better match than Boy C and so on.
“Marly presupposes that the natural position for growth is comfort.”
This is not what I was saying at all, satori. Please don’t make assumptions about what I think. It’s offensive.
I agree with Satori and Chris Brennan wholeheartedly! Astrology is based on the theory of the soul living out it’s need for evolution and enlightenment in a very materialistic plane….it has nothing to do do with the vehicle although the media (and society) would have one believe differently.
I believe that there are no “accidents” or “coincidences” when it comes to living. Everyone whom we meet and sometimes mate with is just the person we need at that moment in time for our, and perhaps their, spiritual growth.
I’ve been married more than once and each relationship has taught me meaningful, life altering changes in perception and attitude.
What I have gained through these turbulent relationships far outweighs what others, or myself, may percieve as my “loss”.
I believe we CHOOSE our life long before we live it…..even the ones with no happy endings.
While it is indeed very tragic the lives Marly so eloquently speaks of it is nonetheless quite strikingly beautiful the sacrifice these souls make to assist in the evolution of humanity.
Ah, Nia! I have thought of this, too, how one can recognize another as a soulmate and it is not necessarily a good thing (if one is speaking of something general like a romantic relationsip).
I have a dear, dear friend who I have an incredible attraction to. I am just in love with her, and believe me, so is everyone we meet (Cancer Sun, Pisces Moon, Leo Rising–a beautiful combo)!
Recently I had a dream in which she was my teacher. It was so nice to tell her about it, too. She teaches me a lot, that’s for dang sure. Love really is just the beginning.
Gotta agree with Marly. I don’t think any soul chooses to live in a warzone, or a despotic nation, or a hellhole. For what purpose would a soul do that? A child in the Sudan whose nose is cut off is going to grow old and think fondly of their sacrifice? Or a girl in Yemen having acid thrown in her face for studying math. Will she find it necessary for the sake of humanity? Just how many tragic types need to come to earth just for “humanity to evolve?” I personally find that ridiculous.
Yes, we definitely grow from tragedies in our lives. But in the U.S., and in many developed parts of the world, it is because we are allowed to grow. Because we have choices, on how we respond to tragedy. In third world, undeveloped wartorn nations, most citizens don’t have any concept of choice. What a waste of life, in my opinion. Not beautiful at all.
what does the natal placements of planet mean if there is no such thing as destiny. say for example, juno. ive read that juno shows or tells us who are we going to end up with. if planets gives us energy then it goes without saying that those energies direct us to where we are supposed to be. i think that our free will only extends to some point. we are presented with choices or options in life which we do not have any control. i wish i was born with different kind of parents but i am still here. i wish those things that happened to me in past, never happened but it did. i wish things is different but it is not.
I agree with Marly and CardinalAngles. It’s hard for me to believe that we choose our life or life path though I’ve heard this thought from quite a few people that I admire.
I’ve wondered if instead of there being free will or some sort of sovereignty/fate over everyone, there are some people who do have complete free will and others whose lives are predestine. Is that possible? And maybe some people only have specific points in their life that are pre-determined and would therefore have a myriad of options or roads to take in order to get there?
Depending on the type of astrology you ascribe to, the planets and their energies can give you a description of who you already are and are becoming or who you have the potential to be. If you can see good/evil in a chart (which I think that you can), then I’d completely ascribe to believing that our natal charts describe who we are, not just our potential.
I believe as Jamie does that our free will is exercised long before we are born. We choose the life we will lead, including every detail of persons, places, events, etc. Free will, once we are here living our chosen life, is important in how we deal with the circumstances, relationships, etc. that we set up beforehand. It is how our soul evolves and grows. So in that way, predestination is correct and so is free will. It’s an awesome system. The spiritual assistance we get before and after our births is another story, but is part of the whole of our existence, which is eternal. Yes, I believe in a divine creator.
Wow, this is an amazing dialogue. I don’t have an answer, but to the point that Marly was making, I think there is a deeper reaction to the worst violence that people experience. I’ve met people in my past work who experienced horrific things, as Marly discussed. They have still sought to bring meaning to their current lives, and even worked to transform what they went through in one way or another. I don’t know about choosing that life before we are born, though, but who really does…
On the flip side, it made me a wreck spiritually to be that close to such pain, even though those who went through this were handling it in their own way. It’s very hard to grasp, or want to understand at a deeper level. This isn’t to idealize the people I have met. It’s just a testament to how humans, after a certain amount of time, work to transform their experiences and pain. And they still have to take care of bills, dishes, their children… they are still human.
I believe astrology can be a huge help in aiding us to know ourselves, and one another, better. And it can warn us of the unseens forces at work in the universe and so guide to excercise our free will positively.
I do not think we are predestined to anything, least of all whom we marry. Asian religious systems do hold such beliefs, and this permits them to cling to the system of ‘arranged marriage’ which can result in repeated rape and abuse of women. Predestination also in a sense absolves individuals of responsibility for their own choices and actions. It’s a symptom imo of authoritarian and patriarchal social systems.
Like belle said : ”I’ve met people in my past work who experience horrific things. They have still sought to bring meaning to their current lives, and even worked to transform what they went through in one way or another.”
___
Whatever horrific obstacle we may have, it is up to us how to deal with it. We could stand behind it crying,we could stand there kicking it, we could be thinking ways to take revenge, we could wish that someone else is having the same obstacle. Personally I dont believe these are the solutions.
___
I know someone who grew up, moving between different foster homes. He met horrible people through out the years(mistreating,stealing,violence,beating, alcohol, drugs).
Now as an adult,.? He manage to take himself out of these situations. -> He now have 2 children that he loves. He brings money and food to his family,he is taking care of them,he bought a beautiful house for them ,and he spends all his free time with them. HHe chose not to block his children with the same obstacle he had when he was younger.
I am not saying that it is easy, I am just saying that it is possible to stop it from moving through generations. At the end, it comes out as our individual free will
meaning, substance, reasons to change, move on, stay, live with it, adapt… its life. We make our soulmates from what we have lived through and learned. Or not.
I agree with everyone, even if different viewpoints have been posted, I think there can be an underlying system which makes all them consistent.
First of all, as eternal souls, I do believe we come to material plane many times to evolve, so there is reincarnation according to me. This makes things more understandable. If we had only one life to live, no one us would agree to be born into difficult circumstances. But if you know you have to come to class everyday as a student (class being mother earth), we would accept having some difficult courses some days of the week, and some fun activities the other days. Each of us have to learn all these courses. You may hate math and enjoy art class, but you have to go through each course, either in the same day or in different days. I think of myself as an ambitious student, I think i enrolled for having all relationship classes in one day, that seems mylife lesson so far. Maybe I wanted to get over with it in one life 
Some others’ lessons are more balanced, a little bit of this and that each life.
so if you think of life this way, maybe people born into horrible circumstances are the brave and strong, and maybe a bit ambitious souls who agreed to face those very difficult life lessons in one life. And people with more comfortable lives may have already gone through the difficult courses in previous lives, or they will go through in next lives.
Hence, overally, there is justice, balance, and all is well. But at any given point in time, life may seem very cruel and unfair. We dont have the whole picture, our perceptions are only restricted to this life’s timeline. If we knew how things would evolve, how we would mature over an infinite span of life, then difficulties wouls seem as just stepping points. At each life, we only see a cross section of the person’s infinite life.
Get A Consultation
Schedule a consultation by phone
Schedule a consultation by email
Read what clients have said about usThanks, we look forward to working with you! :-) - Elsa P
Order a Report
Order a Transit Report
Order a Solar Return Report
Order a Relationship Composite Report
Order both relationship reports, save 10%
Order a Lunar Return ReportHeads Up from Elsa P!
Sign up below to get my free weekly email newsletter covering the astrology of the next week. I send this email out every Thursday.
Recent Blog Comments
- Kashmiri: "Once you have your problem scaled, Saturn comes in to have you ...
- Kenji: I find that I persevere with my first house Saturn, and make use...
- music4am: You're very welcome Elsa, Angie
- mistyoga: I'd say Sun. You are absolutely Authentic.
- Cyress723: I am just coming out of the worst 5 years of my life, I was help...
- dorchid: Yes! And I did it by doing exactly what you state here. Fascinat...
- dorchid: I voted Jupiter. Saturn seems obvious but I think the story-tell...
Recent Board Posts
I’m not sure, but it is a testament to your positive self, Elsa, to say that most people would keep the life they have. I know I would keep mine, but I can’t help but wonder how things would pan out if I had made a few decisions en route.
You know, I’m curious!