Open Question: Do You Bloom Wherever You’re Planted? Astrology’s Three Modalities
Astrology In Real Life…
I consider myself inordinately adaptable to whatever the conditions and this allows me to have a pretty good quality of life. But what if you don’t have this skill? What if happiness is elusive? What if it is contingent upon some special circumstance or on the chance that the stars line up just so?
“I will bloom if and only if, blah, blah, blah happens…”
I think a lot of people are like this. Maybe half? A quarter? Three quarters? I’m wondering, so I’m asking.
And are you predominately a Fixed sign (Leo, Aquarius, Taurus, Scorpio)? Mutable (Gemini, Virgo, Sagittarius, Pisces)? Or Cardinal (Aries, Cancer, Libra, Capricorn)?

49 Responses to “Open Question: Do You Bloom Wherever You’re Planted? Astrology’s Three Modalities”
“Maybe I would have difficulty adapting to jail, ”
Being a Sagittarius I definitely would not bloom there.
I agree, with Dani. It does not matter where I go I always find something to like about the place. If I end up in BFE with no civiliztion within 40 miles I create an environment that enables me to expand in other ways. I do not need familiar faces, objects or land markers to feed my roots. I bloom just about anywhere….but jail!
I am predominantly mutable (lots of Gemini with a sprinkling of Virgo and Pisces) but I have fixed moon and ascendant (Scorpio). I adapt to whatever my environment happens to be and I am stubborn enough to make it all work.
p.s. I love these polls.
Mutable with 5 planets in Sagittarius. ![]()
I don’t think I could bloom elsewhere than where I live right now.
With moon in the 4th house (home, family) plus Cancer rising I need familiar surroundings and faces.
I’ve traveled a lot for business and leisure and often feel homesick after 2 days.
So the answer is no.
I said I don’t know. Well, I seem to succeed where I am planted, but that doesn’t mean I’m happy.
For example, where I am now, I’m doing a decent job, I like the people, the place, well enough, it’s an acceptable step for my career.
but I’m not blooming. I’m not particularly happy. nor am I terribly unhappy. but I don’t think I’m growing. I’m living where outdoor exercise pretty much equals bronchitis, and you know that’s hard on a virgo. I’m primarily mutable, -I can’t bloom in a job where I don’t need a brain- I suffer. I really suffered as a waitress last summer.
I’m at my best when I know when I’m leaving. I like change, I need beauty.
I probably should have said no. I do wilt really easily in some contexts.
Scorpio, Leo rising, Aquarius moon. In spite of this, or maybe because of it, I am fairly adaptable. I believe I could even adapt to jail. I could not, however, adapt to an abusive situation, I think it would drive me to murder.
Yes.Mutable: a lot of virgo
I bloom anywhere, with some reservations.
Within an hour I can absorb the accent of a new place and I have an almost “photographic” memory for routes/directions in places I’ve visited only once, so almost anywhere can seem familiar to me. But, it takes me longer to find rich soil for my roots and start drawing true nutrients. And, although I adapt quickly, I’ll start to fade in a few months if I haven’t found what I need. So, off to another garden for me!
I suppose that means I carry my blooms around with me.
I’m almost evenly split: 5 planets (counting Chiron) in Fixed, 4 planets + ASC in Cardinal, and 3 planets + MC in Mutable. Leo sun with Cancer rising.
OOPS!
I meant to say TWO planets + MC and True Node in Mutable. *blush*
Man, you know it’s going to be a bad day when you read _your own_ chart wrong.
I said yes, I bloom where I’m planted…but with the caveat that sometimes it takes a bit for the bloom to show (have to dig those roots in first!) I’ve done quite a lot of moving in the course of 30+ years, and have had enough experience to know that, for me, failure to thrive where I’m at is not an option.
I’m not sure what my whole chart says, but I can tell you that I’m a Capricorn Sun / Capricorn Moon with (I think?) Aquarius rising.
Bloom where planted–lots of mutable (including a Pisces Moon, which rules my chart & Sun). But my Cardinal Sun (Cancer) discovered that some gardens are more fertile for my type of blossom, and realized it was perfectly capable of replanting me in the garden of my choice instead of just getting blown by the wind. And that is what it did, and I’m perfectly happy with my current place, where I have been quite a long time now and don’t really plan to leave. Yet. Because the mutable still holds out that variety could be nice, and might like to mosey off to new ground someday…
I am equally split between the three, but sun, moon, and ascendant are all in mutable signs (gem and sadge) *chuckle* I’m a bloom-where-you’re-planted kind of girl. I call it making lemonade, and I’m damn good at it.
Aries Sun, Sagde Moon, Scorpio Rising… a whole lot of cardinal and mutable signs in my chart, and a whole lot of fire. Maybe it’s less that I bloom where I am planted than it is I consume where I’m planted.
I like that, Jontelle!
I’m an Aries sun, Moon in Pisces, Rising Sag, and I am also half n’ half cardinal and mutable in my planet placements. I can relate to your description. Although I am also equal parts water and fire, so I guess that’s more like a steam engine. It reminds me of that U2 lyric:
“So she woke up from where she was lying still. Saying ‘I’ve gotta do something about where we’re going’. Step on a steam train. Step out of the driving rain, maybe. Run from the darkness in the night.”
Anyway, on another level, I think anyone can adapt to anything. It’s human nature. Some are more ‘natural’ at it than others, perhaps.
XO…
H
Oooo, not at all!!! I am totally affected, positively or negatively, by my environment. I just wilt in certain environments. Scorpio Sun, Virgo Ascendent, Pisces Moon.
Oohh, this is a hard one. It’s yes and no.
When I move some place, I feel super vulnerable and terribly awkward. And I basically have to rebuild myself (Scorpio Sun+Pluto, Mercury+Saturn) my sense of humor, etc etc, and my idea of home all from stratch. But, I know I will usually adapt, just after a lot of pain and gruesome loneliness and stuff, hehe. Oddly enough, I *make myself go to new places. I think that’s the only way I actually grow. Venus in Sagittarius. And some planets in the 9th house.
Sorry, 9th house in Capricorn. … Chiron in Gemini? I think that’s about it. (Gotta say it’s mostly a Scorpionic influence going on.)
I bloom where I’m planted, but I have to have a few things with me that are my “home”. Photos, art on the wall and a favorite afghan…that would be the Cancer rising, but other than that I have a lot of mutable so maybe that’s why.
You know what, guys, I’ve figured it out at least for me. Blooming probably means thriving as in making the best of situations. I know a Sadge who literally flows from environment to environment, from group of people to group of people, though I don’t know how it was when he was in jail
. Me, however, although I can and need to divulge my shit and feelings (aka “talk”) to anybody and everybody, what happens is that I am discontented in one place, move to another and am discontented the same way like nothing happened! I’m always excited here at home or in school and dream of somewhere else, but as it was in 8th grade I remember getting to Paris and on the first day saying I was depressed, going to London and crying in my room! And then back, pining for Europe! Like college kids say goodbye to their parents and, when their parents leave, they feel the empty nest and miss their children while the (Russian Jewish) college students are heartily pissed at the old world mentality of the parents that live an hour and a half away asking them if they miss them or home when they call five times a day…okay. That’s not an example, that’s me. I meant that when I go home, I get used to it quickly, when I’m in my room in school, I’m pining for something else and in my own little extremely loud thoughts that have pretty much no room for the habituated home, my devoted mother. So yeah, you can also be adaptably pessimistic and discontented.
Or more precisely, the type of adaptable where you very conveniently can forget your family ties and responsibilities, i.e. if you live some place in a small group for two years and when you move to some foreign country for some months, you forget the connections you’ve made and are completely absorbed in the new group of people around you. Seriously, “adaptability” is very convenient for people who want to…uhh..write other people off because they want new scenery. To make new friends and not deal with the commitment of keeping the old.
no.
3 cardinal(+asc), 3 fixed, 4 mutable.
I said no to this question.
I am Leo Sun, Moon and Venus.
Gemini Asc and Cancer Mercury and Mars (both in 4th house).
I bloomed somewhere when I moved through choice. Sadly I left there (for many reasons) 6 years later.
I am NOT blooming where I am. And where I am happens to be my home town!
Seems I can bloom in cities or places with a lot of options and plenty going on. Not so much in stagnant empty wildnernesses.
I think I could probably even handle a complete change of culture. Provided this was something fairly modern and cosmopolitan. I need variety and new faces and places to feel like I am really living. Can’t bear the same old same old.
Loads of Virgo and Pisces (8 planets), so I’m very mutable. But do I bloom where-ever I am? No, not really. Having Cancer rising, Jupiter in Taurus and Neptune in Scorpio so I need to set the rules and boundries and if I can’t, I’m not happy. Finding a comfortable spot to bloom, the right size pot, isn’t all that easy. Once I find it, I don’t like to leave it.
So… yes and no. How very mutable
I’m adaptable but now I know well enough that there’s a difference between surviving and thriving. I tried to live in the suburbs. It was okay, it had its pleasant aspects but I couldn’t bloom there. In adapting to that place, I forgot who I was.
I come from a huuuge mexican- italian upbringing here in so cal. So huge that at 17 I ran away to Kauai to live with a cousin. I grew roots there and built a business so I consider that a “home” because I was so young and spent almost 25 yrs there. But now here I am back in so cal an I love it so much and I’m still flourishing with my business. I’m surrounded by tons of family members and I truly think that when you have a good support system it is easier to bloom. I thank the heavens daily for my large family and blessings. There are times when I would still like to run away to Kauai and I do visit there still because my kids live there… but I think this is where my real roots are.
Well, i take some time to do the blooming….to get familiar to things….and make new friends (which i find i invariably do…wherever i go i find a bunch of like-minded ppl)….then i bloom ! ![]()
But one thing i have found, i never miss any thing/place from the past…rarely get nostalgic. i am too much in the ‘now’ to think of the ‘then’
I am sun in capri, cancer rising, moon-gemini
I forgot to add that I’m a Virgo and Taurus rising.
I’m a Leo Sun, Cancer rising, Pisces Moon with a lot of Neptune in my chart.
I said ‘yes’. It’s kinda my mantra for most of my life, ‘adapt and overcome’. Part of that, I’m sure comes from being an Army brat, but I’m also a Pisces.
But my ascendant is Scorpio, so would that explain why it takes me a year (usually) to get used to the new ‘dirt’ before I bloom again?
I have 5 planets in fixed signs but feel fueled by a 4th house cusp Mars to make a good go of it wherever I’m planted – I immediately “set up house” and move out from there.
Yes, up to a point. My life has been mostly a series of moves, from LA to TX to NV to CA and back to LA. I am now getting ready to move again within the next year (fingers crossed) to the East coast. Every place has a certain purpose for my development, somtimes inner, sometimes outer. I do not know if I will ever settle anywhere, and I do not mind it.
Pisces sun, Scorpio moon, Virgo rising, Sag 4th house (with Mars in Cap there).
I voted yes. I am predominately mutable.
I’m primarily fixed, but my moon is mutable so I feel pretty comfortable adapting. At least I think (says transiting Neptoon).
What choice is there but to bloom where planted? At least that’s how I see it…when it’s really bad, I wallow for a day or two, then I get off my ass, throw out the soggy tissues, and get on with getting on. I can find a silver lining somewhere in damned near anything.
I voted yes. I have been told every where you go there you are,lol. My Sun and Merc are in Gemini my Moon is in Aquarius.
despite having aries sun/venus i’m predominantly spilt (pretty evenly) between mutable and fixed.
i’m highly sensitive to the atmosphere around me. i get around that by filtering my perceptions…. and finding ways to get away from everybody periodically…
What Becca said. I am way Cardinal.
I voted no, am mainly Cardinal. There are some places I just couldn’t hack it, and that’s fine, I just don’t go there.
I used to be very stubborn. Too stubborn! But my Pluto transit in Sagittarius (yes, I’m a Sag), has taught me to live in the now. But that doesn’t always mean I’m happy in the now. It just means that the now is the most important time and that you shouldn’t daydream about the future so much!
I’m a Sag with Pisces Ascendant. But I also have a Moon in Leo,Venus in Scorpio and a Sun-Uranus conjunction. So yes, I have learned to master the art of living in the now!
I’m a cardinal sign yes (cappy). My husband is a fixed sign no (taurus). Seems he’s always gonna be happy when “this” occurs, or “that” happens, or we go “there” instead of here. Drives me freakin’ crazy.
(so i voted “i wish”)(but maybe i don’t, at that… i like what i like and i do know how to find it, when i remember to…)
I voted “I wish”
Course of action (very active Mars I have) is this:
-I figure out quickly what is required of me to maintain sanity and keep the peace around me.
-Plot, immediately, an escape. I’ll take a practical one if need be (Saturn trine) but in a pinch a psychic escape will do. (Neptune trine)
See? I just bloomed by wishing I could bloom. ha ha
I’m a Pisces with a lot of Leo and Aries. My Venus is in Pisces, though.
I’m pretty optimistic. Hope for the best, make the best out of bad situations, yadda yadda.
I will bloom where I’m planted. I roll with the punches.
I don’t know. I think I bloom in my own way the best that I can with what I’m given. I’m not given much sometimes and I still manage to do something. But I wouldn’t say that I thrive on poor dirt.
Sun/moon mutable with cardinal rising..I’m more of a grasshopper…I only land on the blooms! I’ve lived in 8 different countries in the last 12 years. At least 12 different homes in that time period. I don’t root, but I make the best of each hop. Not a lot of earth in my chart, but I do have Saturn in Cap in the 4th…then again, that was childhood.
I’d say no and yes. I can’t bloom in my home town. After a few days I get depressed. I thrive living in a city but in a nice neighbourhood where things are a convenient walk away and there are trees and families everywhere so that i can get out and about. I grew up in the country which was where my escapism thrived but once I wanted more stimulation I was depressed a lot. I prefer city living and doing yoga/meditation to calm my nerves, rather than living somewhere without stimulation but where I get bored easily.
5 libra planets including ascendent (i guess i love the right balance lol), gemini moon, neptune in sag, NN in sag, Jupiter in pisces and saturn in cancer.
We’ll see though. I might get a job that will take me to a small city. I plan on getting an apartment in the busy part of town and a car to drive to the beach etc. Hopefully I’ll thrive and the job will be permanent so I can start a family just as soon as I find a new fella.
Get A Consultation
Schedule a consultation by phone
Schedule a consultation by email
Read what clients have said about usThanks, we look forward to working with you! :-) - Elsa P
Order a Report
Order a Transit Report
Order a Solar Return Report
Order a Relationship Composite Report
Order both relationship reports, save 10%
Order a Lunar Return ReportHeads Up from Elsa P!
Sign up below to get my free weekly email newsletter covering the astrology of the next week. I send this email out every Thursday.
Recent Blog Comments
- Blessed Place: Sounds like a couple of threads on here today hahaha
- Michele: So happy, then, that I chose to schedule Friday for myself and S...
- Caroline: Hahahahahahahahahaha
- brizo: looks like what I wanted to do at work today...>:/
- Elsa: You're welcome. :)
- Nonetheless: Elsa just wanted to thank you for doing these transit watches. I...
- kr: Omggggggggg what an asshole. What a total fucking asshole. (((E...
Recent Board Posts
- Would you approach someone alone if...
- What is your Venus placement's biggest issue in your opinion?
- What Have You Been Cooking Lately?
- Venus, Mars and Romance
- Can You Look Yourself In the Mirror?
- Another Teenage Psychopath: Stabbed Grandmother 90 times, shot h...
- Love, ASTEROIDS and the Age of Men
- I retrograde
- People Who Know You Well
- Marge






Sometimes it is good to bloom a little less where you are planted like my Capricorn friend who remembers his roots in upstate New York. I’m mutable and I know I am surprised how little I notice the difference going home or going far away. It’s not always good to be adaptable, if it means not being mindful or whatever of where you are. Maybe I would have difficulty adapting to jail, but it seems I can forget everybody I know at home if I simply go somewhere, it’s like I’ve been there all that time and I notice the difference almost only when I drive past it before I get there after I’ve been away. It’s like when you jump in the pool and after a while, you forget that you are swimming.