Open Question: “If I Knew Then What I Know Now…”
Ask the collective
Here’s a strange question that came up via a consultation. You know how people say, “If I knew then what I know now” followed by some statement of regret about a decision they made? They usually follow the statement of regret with a shrug or it’s equivalent as if to say, ah well. And it strikes me today how often the information is actually out there in the moment but denied.
We can get information from astrology certainly but we can also get it from reading, thinking, talking to people who are older than us or have more experience, etc. But how often do we do this anyway? It seems most people want to fly solo even if it is straight into a wall so here’s the question:
Why? Why do we so often think that we know best and no one else knows better?

12 Responses to “Open Question: “If I Knew Then What I Know Now…””
when i’ve done that, i always assumed it was about maturity and readiness to process the lesson at hand. i don’t hear a dang thing until i’m ready to hear it.
i think monica also has a good point that we may like to flatter ourselves that our case is special and we can will up a more desirable outcome than average.
This may be an over-simplification but it is what came to mind when I read your post, Elsa:
My daughter was learning to walk when one afternoon she pulled herself up from the kitchen floor and attempted to reach out to balance herself using the side of the kitchen stove. I kept warning her not to touch it: hot, hot, I kept repeating. My girlfriend, mother of a three-year-old who had just dropped by for quick visit, laughed at me and told me to let her go, that Sara was just going to have to experience “hot” before she’d know what hot was. You can imagine that advice ran counter to my natural instinct to protect my daughter from hurting herself.
But in those few moments that afternoon long ago, a simple fact of life was perfectly illustrated. Sure enough, Sara learned quickly what hot was and was all the better for it.
Would you agree that so often in life, we really do have to experience a thing for ourselves if we are to learn/gain anything from it. And, how many times do some of us have to touch that stove before we know that hot will burn?
My little daughter (now a fine, young woman) learned quickly. Still does. I can’t say that I always do.
I tend to think I will understand how I am going to react better than someone who isn’t me will.
I learn better from trial and error, and by “doing it” — it isn’t really that I think I know best & screw everyone else.
In general, it’s good to consult with others, listen and learn from their experience. But having said that, why do we so often think that others know best and we do *not* know better? Doing what others have done gives us the same results that others have gotten. To produce a better effect, we have to use their experiences as a foundation, but ultimately follow our own intuition. In the end, nobody knows what’s best for us better than ourselves!
I’m with AB on this one. My regrets are usually based on “why did I not do the thing my gut told me to?”
my regrets are more from not listening to myself….
Good Question. It’s like we can see it when we can see it.”
I’m someone who ALWAYS prefers to ‘pay for help’ rather than impose on my friends.
I earn my keep by being paid to advise and I like the ‘clean-ness’ if that’s such a word of paying someone for advice. That doesn’t mean you won’t have to work with my defendedness during the process but it does mean I have invested ALOT in the process besides my time and your fondness for me so I’m motivated to learn.
Plus I never have to hear at a really low minute from my friend “for crying out loud, didn’t we all tell you that guy was a total loser?”
I will say if I do not follow the suggestion its always a case of ‘I CAN’T” (meaning MY ability) reather than DON’T (I know better) or WON’T (I’m too willful).
That means I hear the suggestion but probably simply don’t have the ability or maybe haven’t done the requisite footwork that allows me to put the good direction I’ve received into practice.
Maybe i have another step to take or another painful lesson in front of me before I’m
I ready to ‘do the right thing’ for myself.
I’m thinking about doing something really stupid right now. I’m on the outside looking in at my intention. I definitely don’t think I know better than the others. I’m just hope I can do better for myself. That’s the question.
Huh
good question. wish I knew the answer.
I have to learn it for myself. I have to touch the hot stove, and get burned, to understand it.
That sucks, let me tell you. It would be so much easier to listen to advice from other people and actually take it. But then I wouldn’t learn what I’m supposed to learn.
Sometimes I have to touch the hot stove over and over and over again to make sure it is really hot and then sometimes I am still not sure,lol. I too have always (usually) have to learn things the hard way. I want to have the experience.
Get A Consultation
Schedule a consultation by phone
Schedule a consultation by email
Read what clients have said about usThanks, we look forward to working with you! :-) - Elsa P
Order a Report
Order a Transit Report
Order a Solar Return Report
Order a Relationship Composite Report
Order both relationship reports, save 10%
Order a Lunar Return ReportHeads Up from Elsa P!
Sign up below to get my free weekly email newsletter covering the astrology of the next week. I send this email out every Thursday.
Recent Blog Comments
- notch: Sleepwalking. I am sleepwalking. Nothing seems real. Has the sun...
- notch: I thought overt happiness had been outlawed. Must be my prgresse...
- notch: What does "putting alot of sexual energy out" look like? Someti...
- Satori: :D
- Chili: Just learning about Vesta. Mine is Virgo in the 8th house. Of co...
- Kenji: This is bang on for a lot of my relationship issues. It has been...
- CArRiE: Saturn going through Libra (my 12th house) has already been help...






Hmmm, I think it’s because people like to think that they’d be the exception to the “usual” rule. Probabilities don’t really deter me from things…you do something and let’s say 90% there’s an unfavorable result…that still means that 10% of the time there’s a favorable one… and you hope your part of that 10% LOL!