23
Open Question: Astrology-Based Advice For Scorpio Man In New Relationship With Libra Man
Ask the collective
Dear Elsa,
I’m a gay man who recently met a Libra man who is two years older than me (They are 55 and 57). We communicate well, joke around and have very similar dietary and exercise habits. He is much more calm than I am which balances things out. My question
is that he seems aloof at times and very into his job and caring for his dog and is a homebody.
Any advice on how a Scorpio should understand a Libra man besides just chilling and letting things take their course?? Thanks!!
Scorpio Man
United States
Dear Scorpio, letting things take there course is always the best plan. General tips for Libra - well they love to partner. Once partnered they can relax and it sounds like this is what this man is doing.
You also specifically state he is balancing things out which is the job of Libra. This means if you act one extreme they will typically act the other but if you do too much of this (Scorpio manipulating), you risk pissing off the Libra which is always disastrous. Because while Libra does try very hard to be pleasant, if you get one to blow, you can expect a bloodbath.
Good luck
Anyone else?
Click to see the chart full size TIME IS APPROXIMATE
Submit your own open question
25
Are You A Lesbian? We Want To Know Because We’re Looking For One Around Here…
Astrology in real life
A couple days ago my friend, satori who is a Pisces told me that she connected me to the mundane world. “I connect you to the mundane and everyone else who is mundane, I connect to the other,” she said, and I laughed. I think it’s pretty funny when you have to get a Pisces to ground you; however she is not the first.
My sister is the first Pisces who attempted to connect me with the mundane. I say attempted because I am pretty sure she would tell you she failed and I was thinking about this today. I recalled something I wrote awhile back and meant to pull it up and post it but this came out instead…
My sister loves high level shopping (think Posh Spice) but she is stuck with a sister who could care less. Back when, it was big talk in her circles. No one could believe she had a sister who oblivious to clothing and makeup.
At one point, when I was about 30 she grilled me wanting to know if I was a lesbian. Apparently this was a theory amongst her and her friends. It was the best explanation they could come up I guess. I am not a clotheshorse, therefore I am a lesbian!
Continue reading Are You A Lesbian? We Want To Know Because We’re Looking For One Around Here…
24
Gay Aquarian In Love With Elusive Man: Astrology-Based Advice
Dear Elsa,
I am a gay man and met a guy in Feb this year. A few weeks later, he told me he could not have a relationship with me as he had found out his mother could be dying of cancer. Therefore he could not be happy whilst his and his family’s world was falling apart. I was devastated as I had already fallen in love with him.
Over the last few months we have stayed in touch and I have found out he has been seeing other guys, which has been really upsetting. I confronted him as to why he is seeing others when we could be together. He basically said he didn’t want a relationship with me or anyone at the moment and denied sleeping with anyone. At one point in May he decided that he wanted us to try again. I was happy with this but very soon he closed up again and said no.
I have been patient yet hurting all the time. In October his mother sadly passed away. I saw him and tried to support him although I still know he is busy dating other guys. I have tried walking away but cant. I’m still in love with him. For some reason he wont walk away either.
Is there any hope for us?
Aquarian
England
Dear Aquarian,
No, I don’t think there is any hope of changing the dynamic of this relationship and it suits you perfectly as is, whether you realize this or not.
As an Aquarian with Venus in Aquarius you want a lot of space and with this man, you get it. You also have your Moon and Mars in Aries so you like the challenge he provides. He must be perennially hunted, see? But most of all it’s the pining.
You have Venus square Neptune and there is a part of you that is addicted to pining for this un-gettable man but check this:
If you get him… if you actually get this guy and nail him down I guarantee you the situation will flip on you. Instead of where you are now, you will be pining for freedom and challenge. Pretty trippy, huh?
I admit that living in this hall of mirrors with various drives conflicting is a job. However it is your job and at least you’re not bored or boring.
Good luck.
Need advice? Ask here!
Subscribe to the Elsa Blog
Info on scheduling a personal consultation
17
Virgo Woman Wonders If Her Aquarian Man Is Gay: Astrology-Based Advice
Dear Elsa,
I am living with my boyfriend of four years in his very small hometown while we take a break between college and grad school. His best friend since childhood lives a short trip away so we see him often.
I think the best friend is in love with my boyfriend. Neither has ever expressed an interest in the same sex but when they are together there is such energy and chemistry. I hadn’t thought of it until my mother visited and was concerned because when the two of them are together, they kind of gang up on me. The teasing starts to have a really mean edge sometimes.
So now I can’t stop thinking about it and noticing little things that I didn’t before. My boyfriend is an Aquarius.
Should I ask him straight out if he might be gay? Or if his friend might be? Should I first try to figure out whether my own insecurity is making me jump to conclusions? Or wonder if my mother’s ‘concern’ is actually sabotage?
I don’t want to jeopardize the relationship with damaging accusations, but I’m starting to feel lonely and unattractive and that’s no good!
Virgo Girlfriend
Italy
Dear Girlfriend,
I really have no way of telling if your boyfriend is gay or not. I suspect he is not considering he has spent four years with you and seems comfortable enough interacting with another man. Point being: if he wants it, there it is. You are obviously open-minded so it’s not like the sky is going to fall if he come up with this so it makes me think while his friend may very well be gay (and in love with him) your boyfriend is merely being Aquarian.
To address all points, the fact that you suspect your mother makes me suspect your mother as well so I factor her out and it leaves me to wonder why you are feeling lonely and unattractive. Is it because he is neglecting you in favor of his friend? Or is it because he is boring you?
Because it sounds to me as if he could be being himself (a detached, non-judgmental, not that interested in sex, Aquarian) and you could be finding out you want something very different in a man and on this I have some personal experience.
I had an Aquarian beau once and I was just a million times more sexual and tactile than he was. I also had a very close friend (Ben - we’re still friends 20 years later), who is gay and I asked him… ‘Is this guy gay or what?”
He asked me how much time the man spent with me and I told him he called me 10 times a day and saw me 5 or 6 times a week. Verdict? Not gay.
“Gay men like men, Elsa. They really have very little interest in women but they love men and there is no way they are going to waste that much of their time in the company of a woman when there are men… everywhere.”
So apply that when debating your boyfriend’s sexual preference and beyond that, here is my advice:
I would definitely not confront him about his sexuality. Instead, focus on what you are getting from the relationship. Because it sounds to me as if you are not getting what you want and need, regardless if he is gay, straight or zebra.
Good luck.
Need advice? Ask here!
Subscribe to the Elsa Blog
Info on scheduling a personal consultation
9
Gay Man In Long Term Relationship Wonders If He Should Cut Losses With His Inattentive Partner: Astrology-Based Advice
Hi Elsa,
I have been dating a guy for 3 years and we just split up last week. Since meeting, we clicked from day one and have been great the whole time. The problem is that from my point of view, he never puts in enough effort into the relationship and any time we do anything special it’s because I arrange it. Weekends away, movies, dinner, holidays, even going to the beach! For the first 2 years he was clueless enough to forget birthdays, Valentine’s day and even recently asked what date our anniversary is on (coming up next month). It’s on the 15th, the same day of the month as my birthday.
I am guilty of putting him down which I regret doing and I know he doesn’t deserve that but little things he does frustrate me and I told him I needed space and that was it. I know he loves me, and I love him, but I just don’t know if I’m expecting too much or if I really am just asking for a little more respect and caring in the relationship. I know we could get back together, but have agreed not to communicate and give each other space for a few weeks. Move on or go back???
Gay Man
Australia
Dear Man,
This is a great question and while I can’t make a decision for you, I am happy to offer my opinion - and in my opinion you should definitely go back. Go back because you love him and he loves you and this is not all that easy to find.
As to whether you are asking for too much, well you are not. But you asking him to give you something that does not come easy for him and making yourself miserable in the process. In other words you are focusing on the lack, which while it may be real becomes insignificant if you opt to refocus.
The idea of refocusing on the positive goes without saying but you can go much further if you like. You can opt to raise the bar on yourself around what kind of lover you are - and rather than looking to how he can improve, make yourself better than ever.
Make yourself better than ever by being the kind of lover who does not ride their partner’s ass all the time and you will be in demand and loved like never before. And oddly enough, when your partner perceives your higher value, he is very like to start hitting up those birthdays which he knows damned well are important to you… before someone else decides to do it for him. So this is my advice:
Get off his ass, get on your own, watch the result and marvel. And the astrology?
You have hard aspects from Saturn which does give a tendency towards seeing the glass as half-empty. Thing is you can turn this around with work and I promise that if you do, you will see everything in your life improve.
Good luck.
Need advice? Ask here!
Subscribe to the Elsa Blog
Info on scheduling a personal consultation
5
Gemini In Love With Bisexual Aries - Can This Thing Work? Astrology-Based Advice
Hi Elsa,
A few months ago I started seeing this Aries woman who identifies as bisexual. I see only women. We had a few casual encounters but nothing came of that since she was seeing several other people at the time. When we did see each other, it was due to her persistence. I liked her but was afraid of getting too close.
This summer we both ended up living in the same city. We started seeing each other again and moved in together. Everything seemed perfect and we got along great. When I headed back to school, she confessed that she had fallen in love with me. At this point we had been rather exclusive for nearly three months, although technically we were in an open relationship.
Based on my track record of not doing serious relationships she predicted I’d be scared off, but I wasn’t. As a matter of fact I realized within the week that I was in love with her as well, though I never had a chance to tell her. Right around this time she started becoming more distant, calling and emailing less. The subject of whether we were exclusive or not came up. I wanted to be exclusive. She didn’t. We ended it over the phone but decided to still remain friends.
I visited her not long after the break up and we ended up hooking up. I thought we’d start seeing each other again but this didn’t happen. I was really confused and still am. One week she’ll call me multiple times a day, the next I’ll be lucky to get an email. Yet every time I see her in person she tells me that she really desires me and loves me. Last time I did see her in person I resisted her advances because this is not the type of relationship I want with her. I really love this girl but the mixed signals are driving me insane.
Sometimes I think she really does love me but is hoping to somehow persuade me to be in the kind of relationship she wants, one in which she has me but is free to see other people. I’m willing to stick it out if I somehow know that we’ll get back together when she is done sorting out her business. I hear ultimately Gemini and Aries are a good match. Is it worth it or should I just move on? Am I delusional?
Gemini in Love
United States
Dear Gemini,
Your gal pal told you she was bisexual and apparently she was not kidding. So yes of course she is trying to talk you into the type of relationship that will satisfy her needs, which is exactly the same thing that you are trying to do to her. Can you see this?
What you have here is a power struggle, or a struggle to control. You want her to cram her foot into your shoe and she wants you to cram your foot into hers. Is this ever going to work? Not comfortably.
As for her hot and cold business - Aries is notorious for loving the thrill of the chase but loathing the security and structure - which with Venus in Cancer and Mars in Capricorn is something you crave.
I think you’re getting the picture. Very hard to make this one work, I am thinking it’s not meant to but other may disagree and can let you know in the comments.
I am sorry and good luck.
Need advice? Ask here!
Subscribe to the Elsa Blog
Info on scheduling a personal consultation
22
Rape And The Triple Pisces - Standing On Principles, It’s All Due The Double Aquarius, Angela Davis
Astrology in real life
I wanted to come back on the Triple Pisces. I rejected that woman, hard and I wanted to explain what drove me mostly because although the story stands alone, things are far more interesting when you’ve privy to more of the root.
I try to expose the roots when time permits which is why I think I so many Scorpios read here. It makes a nice meal. It makes things more satisfying but anyway, I went to see Double Aquarius, Angela Davis speak.
You can read her rich history but I saw her about 15 years ago in the early 90’s which was post her history, history when hers was a household name circa, 1970-72. In whatever case someone invited me to hear her speak (about rape) and having nothing better to do that evening, I showed up and was completely taken with her. Continue reading Rape And The Triple Pisces - Standing On Principles, It’s All Due The Double Aquarius, Angela Davis
9
Aries Lesbian Contemplates Moving In With Cancer Woman And Her Three Kids: Astrology-Based Advice
Dear Elsa,
My girlfriend is an early Cancer. We’ve been dating off and on for about 2 years. We’re thinking of living together in 4 months or so. I have no kids but she has 3 boys and currently going through a new separation with her husband of 16 years.
I am very protective of my belongings, some being very personal and expensive. I also need my space especially with 3 kids and a dog to contend with. I told her I would need to have my own room out of the 4 rooms in the house. She is moving next weekend. I need a room to store my expensive things and for my private “get away” space to assure a more tranquil living environment and prevent issues with her very busy touchy feely kids. She already promised her kids they would each have their own room unfortunately and this may be a deal breaker for me. The garage is not an option as a safe space for me and my things.
If I move in I would be paying half the rent in the house. I don’t wanna be selfish but this may prevent me from being interested in living with her as, as you have read, this is an already tricky situation being that we both are women and this is her first same sex relationship. I know this is a loaded situation here but is requiring my own room or space silly? Should I by default, allow my things to get broken and tampered with by her kids to prove I love her and capable to make this commitment? Her kids are 18, 10, and 7. OMG!
Aries In Love
United States
Dear Love,
It is not unreasonable or selfish to want your own space but it probably is completely unrealistic to think you are going be able to have this while living with a woman, three children and a dog unless you can afford a house with a separate wing… which it sounds like you cannot.
I think you will probably be miserable if you move in with your girlfriend and also that you will make others miserable… so the fact you are looking at this in a harsh light is good. Because she has a responsibility to her kids and if she is counting on your to pay half the rent and you are ready to balk… well I think you should tell her right away that you are having your doubts.
And don’t think I don’t see your side! I have Libra you know. And it sounds like when she promised her kids they would each have their own bedroom… knowing your conditions, well as far as I am concerned, she sold you out right there.
So no. I would not recommend you move. You are too independent and kids are fixtures, you can take my word on that. Your girlfriend is also telling you one thing (you will be accommodated) but taking opposite action, so you know. Looks like you’d be jumping into a fire to me.
Good luck.
Need advice? Ask here!
Interested in a personal consultation? Click here for more info.
17
Homosexuality and Suicide: A Cautionary Tale
A public service message
This is for Mercury in Scorpio and today’s Moon in Capricorn. Regarding the young man from the soldier’s church who committed suicide last week.
“I went in there and his mother is devastated. His girlfriend… they were going to get married and she is devastated. I mean, devastated. Why does someone do that, P? What is so bad you have to go and kill yourself?”
I didn’t answer. Continue reading Homosexuality and Suicide: A Cautionary Tale
9
Open Question And Update: 20 Year Old Man Loses His Gay Lover of Five Years To A Woman Who Is Pregnant: Pluto Transit
Now and then someone writes me months after the fact to let me know how the advice I gave them helped them and this letter was particularly moving. I remembered this guy instantly and if you’ve been reading here awhile, I bet you do too.
I cut him no slack and I wanted to publish this letter because it’s obvious he’s done a lot of work since and the results left me feeling humbled and inspired. I wanted to share the emotion and also, he thanks two other people in here (Marc is one of them) and with a little luck, they will see this.
Last, gives me a chance to make a point I have been meaning to make for long time. That is, I feel people with emphasis on Virgo and Pisces (or the 6th and 12th houses) must serve or suffer, but I think it is wise to discriminate who you serve.
For example, if you sacrifice your life to your alcoholic husband, that’s probably not so good. But then someone like this comes along. Someone with great heart, where investment in them pays off. Not for the person serving personally, but to the collective at large because this man has obviously advanced himself and become a source, not a sink.
So now he has another question and I think we should help him. Mercury is in Scorpio. How about we (the collective / Scorpio) write something (Mercury) to heal and empower (Scorpio) this man?
Thank you,
Elsa
Hi Elsa,
I wrote to you away back in February about a friend of mine with who I’d grown rather intimate. 20 Year Old Man Loses His Gay Lover of Five Years To A Woman Who Is Pregnant: Pluto Transit
I’m writing to say thank you Elsa for your help and advice, and the subsequent outcome. I took your advice, and took a step back. I see now all the mistakes I made, and I am at that point where I am sincerely sorry for everything that went on, let alone embarrassed at how I acted. It was so naive of me to think that when I ‘outed’ him, he’d come running back to me with open arms. But I’m past all that and realize now that we were friends and that’s all and although we let each other down, we’re far better out of each others lives.
Now, I know what I really have. I give my friends a hug just that bit tighter, and I’m a lot more ferociously loyal to my friends. I’ve accepted the moral of the story and learned my lesson.
I started college this year as well, and I’m doing really well at that, and really want to get into university next year. I’m not out on the hunt for Mr Right, but no doubt things will work out when they’re meant to. College and my prospective career, family and my mates, are going to come first.
Thank you so much for your advice Elsa, you were firm with me and it’s helped. So did the two comments left by two gentleman, and I’m very grateful for older, more experienced gay men to take time out of their lives and give advice to me.
I can’t help but wonder though how I’ll get on with college and whether or not I have the ability to progress to university. I also wonder if I’ve the aptitude to be a writer… a novelist.
Thank you Elsa once more, I am so glad I discovered your site.
Young Man In(Less) Turmoil
Scotland
Recent Comments
- isabelle: w/ a mostly fixed emphasis I truly dislike or resist change ...
- wyrdling: i guess it's a good omen for the collective solar return, hm...
- isabelle: yeah!...
- Heather: Kashmiri LOL at the cute butts....sounds like you have great...
- Snapdragon: Flip away, Kashmiri - not enough hair? Flip anyway. They'l...
- goddess: y'all are NUTS! LMAO!...
- kashmiri: happy independence day, my lovely southerly neighbours. i ho...



