Aug
26

Open Question: Astrology And Charity: Who Do You Give To And Why?

Ask the collective

givebloodgivelife.gifOne of the regular readers wrote to ask where you would look in a chart for the best opportunity to give. Her specific words were; “The best type of charity for a person to give to?”

I am not sure I understand the question but think the topic in general is grand and I have given this some thought.

I consider myself a giving person, in fact my life is pretty much about two things… service and getting laid. But as any innately giving person can tell you, it is important to come up with some kind of criteria and/or boundary around who and what you give too unless you want to be a bled dry doormat.

Some years ago I came up with criteria which is fairly elegant and I share this with clients who are like me, with good results. I tell them you can give to anyone anywhere (Pisces) but I elect to discriminate (Virgo) who I give to.

For example you can donate your life a man who beats you… your money to an alcoholic or other drug addict and that will be that. You will be giving but not much will come of it. Alternately you can apply some logic and probably get a better result.

Personally, I try to give to people who give and avoid giving to black holes. In other words, charitable people receive my charity and greedy people I leave to starve.

Now you could argue that the greedy people need the charity more than the others but I will not agree with you because I see greedy people not as victims but as perpetrators who I am obviously not going to support. Giving is a function of Jupiter and in theory a gift should grow so if I’ve got a seed, I am going to want to put that in fertile ground rather than a sink hole. I want my energy to shore up someone who shore up someone…

There is another kind of giving (Pisces) where you give and let God or the universe decide who gets your gift and I do this as well. For example when you donate blood, who winds up with your gift is entirely out of your hands.

So these are my charities… who do you give to and why?

submit your own open question


advertisement below

21 Responses to “Open Question: Astrology And Charity: Who Do You Give To And Why?”

1.
kashmiri
kashmiri

I give in a few ways:

-tack on a coupon for the Food Bank at the grocery store (or buy a couple of things and put it in the bin)

-regularly donate what I don’t need to a collective that supports women and children leaving abusive homes

-I volunteer, not a huge amount but I would say I give 3 months out of every 2 years. the last place was a drop-in centre for women on the street.

And I am a very kind person who is willing to have a conversation with anyone, no matter how effed up or scruffy they are.

Being kind is an act of generosity in my world.

 
2.
Elsa
Elsa

Well, kashmiri, I can vouch for you. Just last week someone contacted me wanting to contact you for help of some kind and you (humbly) stepped right up. Made me feel good. :)

 
3.
foxxy
foxxy

I give to the food bank, and I donate blood, and I’ll usually drop some change in the boxes you see by cash registers if I’m familiar with the charity.

I give to the food bank because I’ve been hungry and everyone should have food.

I give blood because I don’t see why I wouldn’t. I’m guarenteed ot stumble across a clinic somewhere at least once every six months and it only takes like 20 minutes. I’m type o negative and really. 20 minutes of my time and I maybe save someone’s life? I can’t come up with any excuse strong enough to not donate.

I appreciate organized charities. I respect the SPCA and the Toronto Humane Society and Salvation Army and so many other places. They do good work. I look at the loonie or twoonie in my hand and really what junk am I going to spend it on? Its better off going where its needed.

 
4.
Tam
Tam

I give monthly to Heifer International. Quarterly to Solar Cookers International. I adopted a Navajo native elder. If there is a 5th Saturday in the month I work with Habitat for Humanity. I have been to New Orleans twice to work. I help to deliver wood to the poor in the winter and I visit The Hunger Site everyday to donate a cup of food. I think that’s all.

 
5.
Danielle
Danielle

Elsa, your comments remind me of my Aquarian grandmother forbidding me to give to street beggars and showing me a newspaper article in which one who frequented the corner near my grandfather’s office died a multimillionaire. I still felt bad every time we passed one.

I have a Pices moon and I work in a “helping” profession, thus I’ve given the coat off my back to the same elderly street woman 3 times. The first 2 she traded them for something else she needed. She told me this on the third instance, when I inquired. She also pointed out that I had made no restrictions on the use of my prior gifts.

You Virgos are probably rolling your eyes at this point, but I disagree about giving to addicts being ineffective. It just requires a lot of patience. I’ve personally seen positive results, though it did take years. Some people need more help than others.

In the final analysis, I don’t think it matters how you give, only that you do.

 
6.
maureen
maureen

Read to kids in a literacy program once a month..and this year a handful of us are starting a journalism club for the same kids.. going to teach them how to make a documentary! By the way, we had a meeting two weeks ago to draw up a list of what we’d need to pull this off(transportation for kids, two computers, disposable cameras, etc), and wondered if anyone would nibble. Well, between the school district and another local charity, we’re getting everything we asked for. There is a web of generosity in play here, and I love that.

 
7.
doublecappy
doublecappy

I wonder how much of what I do makes a difference (probably Cappy being hard on myself). I’m a coach, and I have clients thanking me all the time about my work. I help them tell their stories.

Similarly, I’m telling a story on screen that will hopefully impact a large community.

I’m trying to volunteer in a children’s cancer center now - something I’ve always wanted to do and all the signs lately have pointed to my needing to be there soon. But there’s still some fear there, like “can I handle this?” - but the signs are just unmistakable.

I’m also wondering how to implement teaching/coaching writing in hospital environments - as a kind of healing tool - possibly with kids.

Beyond that, I’ve been asked by a lot of people to help heal - that it’s my calling, and I’m always questioning in what capacity. So I guess I’m not there yet.

Day to day, I’d just like to be available for small things - random acts of kindness and helping someone out. I look all the time for opportunities.

 
8.
Jilly
Jilly

I have Jupiter in the 8th house and Sag. on my 12th house cusp.

I don’t feel comfortable responding to that question in public, LOL.

 
9.
kashmiri
kashmiri

ha ha, Jilly!
Thanks Elsa, that made me happy. I like helping people.

 
10.
Jessica
Jessica

“my life is pretty much about two things… service and getting laid.”
word.

 
11.
Ana
Ana

I like that philosophy. Resources are limited, may as well give it to those who will make maximum use out of it. In a way, giving to those who waste gifts (use it for booze, drugs, etc.) is detrimental in the larger picture, because it means another person who would have used that gift (to better their life, help themself and in turn help others) is not given that chance.

Donating blood is a life-giving gift so I like to do that whenever possible. My favorite gift to give is time - and I like to give it to children. Mentoring, helping with homework, doing stuff together, being a friend to talk to, a support for a kid who needs one. I’ve always wanted to volunteer at an orphanage.

 
12.
goddess
goddess

i give different ways. to my friends and family. to places where i’m getting something - emotional, spiritual, growth. to kids charities. some writing, encouraging others in online communities, support for software i use, consultations for web work, and i try to always be nice to clerks and people i run accross during my day.

i don’t give to addicts - am a virgo, but it’s not because it’s a bottomless pit; it’s because i’ve worked with them and had family members with issues, and i believe money or material gifts that can be traded for money or whatever are contributing to the downward spiral. i decided a long time ago if someone wants to slowly kill themselves, they will have to do it without my help. (it is, however, much nicer when you feel like what you put out is being put to good use, too.)

 
13.
Rainie
Rainie

I try to donate blood at least once a year, twice when I can. They make it so easy; a van comes to my job site about twice a year so I eat while I work and spend lunch in the van. I walk dogs at the pound, although I think that is more for me than for the dogs! I give money to animal welfare groups occasionally.

As a Virgo and addict in recovery, I don’t think giving an addict money or anything they can sell is the best help you can give them. From my experience, it takes very little to keep an addict addicted and any excuse to keep using will do. At the same time, they’re your gifts so you decide where they go, ya know?

 
14.
spinner
spinner

One day in the not too distant future I will give more of my time. For now I just give cash to charities, a little more each year whenever possible. I do work a lot so free time is valuable. [And if I am spending a little time almost every day here at the Elsa's blog, than it must hold a significant value for me...and it does... and I can elaborate on that sometime, if you like.] I am torn sometimes on the subject of giving to street people and tend to give to the organizations that help them. I am not a very good judge of people that suffer from addictions. Is anyone? Certainly some of the professionals that work in this field have a better idea about this. It must be an incredible challenge. I hold these professionals in very high esteem and my heart goes out to the people that they help.

 
15.
wyrdling
wyrdling

people who need it and will use it. (not waste it)
at least, that’s my general tendency

 
16.
goddess
goddess

spinner, i’ve worked in a detox for 2 and a half years. many of the people working there had a history of addictions, although a few (like myself) did not. while you saw indications people wanted to change their lives at times, there seemed little way to tell who was going to do something about it and who was just going through the motions. and the people with the histories were not any better at “seeing” it than anybody else. perhaps they had more empathy, though. i don’t know. i was so clueless. i was shocked the first time we had a repeat client in detox. I was like, “Wait? Didn’t he get treatment? Isn’t he supposed to be all better now?” LOL. it was similar, when i’ve worked with people who are homeless and the like. some were struggling to improve their lives; others were users and nothing more.

i know it detox expecially burned me out on the social services field completely. i felt like the experience was leaving me less compassionate as a human being, so i got out. i find different ways to express my need to help now.

 
17.
doublecappy
doublecappy

Goddess, that’s interesting. I’m trying to find the right field to donate time/help/skills. And I am beating myself up about being “choosy” - like I go from women’s shelter, to sick kids, to writing groups with cancer survivors. I’m afraid of burnout I think, and it’s hard to know how much I can handle without trying it - but I don’t want to get involved then pull out. (Oh the life of a libra moon).

So I’m glad you hit on this.

I’m wondering if the solution is to develop a skill that I can apply (and I have a few in mind) with different groups to serve them - I’m a writing coach and teacher, and also thinking about training in phoenix rising (a form of yoga therapy).

Hmm…

Thanks for helping me think this through some more!

 
18.
mudlikesubstance
mudlikesubstance

blood, time, skills. They go to causes that I’d work for if I had the ability to stay in the nonprofit field without burning out. My favorite, currently, is a training and repair shop for bikes. They train kids and adults to repair their own bike, they repair the junked bikes from city cleanups and sell them to keep the lights on. All volunteer with the exception of two mechanics paid on staff and a halftime volunteer coordinator. That’s worth my time and energy to get more people involved. Healthy for the community all the way around.

 
19.
Drea
Drea

I never thought about my giving in terms of my sign. But I just realized that I give to organizations that support families, the hungry and the poor (micro-lending).

These choices reflect my moon sign. Cancer loves to nurture, loves food and my moon sits in the 2nd house. I think this also reflects the fact that I am driven far more by my emotions than my logic. Although I think I have a good rationale for my choices and I have done some research into my picks.

Some of the posters mentioned their moon signs too. I’d be interested in discovering how their moon impacts their choice of charity!

I don’t give as much as I could and should. I would really like to give more of my time. But I’m not sure how. My job has unpredictable hours and I’m so drained that by the weekend, I sleep half of it away.

But I’ve been wanting to volunteer for something unrelated to my job for a long time. Of course, some might say all the extra time I spend at work is my donation to my agency and its mission is charity as I don’t get paid for it!

 
20.
spinner
spinner

goddess- thank you!

 
21.
goddess
goddess

you’re welcome, spinner. :)

doublecappy, i worked in the social services for over a decade and did a lot of this on a paraprofessional level. i’ve worked in women’s shelters, with the “serverly persistently mentally ill” (usually schizophrenics but also bipolar, borderline, and people with dissociative identity disorder), homeless, suicide hotline, the whole gamut to some degree or another. i had planned on going to grad school to be a psychologist…of all this, it was detox specifically that burned me out because that population is a bitch to work with. many are immature, some are ill, depressed, sick, and angry. nobody gets put in a detox unit unless their life is pretty fucked up. for me, ultimately, i think it was because i didn’t feel like i was making a differece.

you’d be sitting outside, 3 or 4 in the morning, listening to somebody’s story. they all had stories and by then, we’d have done massive paperwork to admit them (20 page! questionnare if someone was coherent enough) - and usually doing a smoke break. they all smoke…there was an otherworldly quality about these people’s stories. you were constantly watching lives dissengrate before your eyes.

since 80% of people who quit using start up again, you see people fail repeatedly. we had regulars and you slowly, gradually watch people die. i mean, i’m sure some got it together. but you never saw that or knew it. you saw the people that were not making it.

you approach idea sounds like an interesting one, and probably a good way to spread it around. i’d say your gut is the best indictor of burnout, and make sure to take plenty of time off as you need. i also found the phrase “I didn’t create it and I can’t fix it.” to be of help… :lol:

 


You can also just...


Get A Consultation

Elsa P

I'm available for consultations! You can schedule a consultation by phone or a consultation by email. You can also read what clients have to say about my consultations. Thanks, I look forward to working with you. :)  - Elsa P

 
 

More


 
 
Get this widget!

Recent Blog Comments

  • Mari: Sheer class and poise She was the only and best thing about ...
  • Mari: Thank you for that! I also looking forward to the continued ...
  • Mokihana: I've loved this song for as long as it has been around. Now...
  • Elsa: On the reanimation theme, it makes me think of the soldier's...
  • Lucy: Out a window?! The Pisces part of me is like EW THAT'S GROSS...
  • Lupa: SaDiablo, I think either way you have to walk away but the o...
  • Ro: Ehhh, I wasn't pissed off when I first read this last night....