Sep
16

Saturn In Virgo: The Case against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering by Michael J. Sandel

Outtakes and Various Other Sundries…

case against perfectionI’m reading this book, ‘The Case against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering .” It caught my eye at the library because it seemed relevant to Saturn in Virgo. It’s occurred to me that it’s my generation, with Pluto in Virgo who are trying to make people perfect.

I haven’t finished the book though I admire it. For one thing it’s a mere 150 pages and not a word wasted. Secondly, in spite of the title it seems to me midway through, the author is arguing FOR genetic engineering so I will interested to see how (or if) he turns this around.

But aside from that the author presents one scenario after another that really gets you thinking. For example, what if they split sports down the middle? Regular people on one field and enhanced (by whatever means) people on another? Who would the spectator go to see? The super athlete or the normal guy?

I am pretty sure the masses would go see the super athlete which seems a sad comment until and the author makes you think hard when he compares this to the first running shoes. Purists said no. They said it would ruin the sport.

He mentioned musicians who take beta blockers to calm their nerves before performing. Are they “enhanced”? Purists say yes. They feel overcoming the fright is part of live performance… implying you’ve got a bunch of drones playing. The people on the other side feel this merely allows nervous people to play as well as they can.

If a steroid is no good… creates an enhanced athlete, then what does a fortified Power Bar do? Point being where is the line??

There are parents who have their children’s pediatricians give them growth hormone if it looks as if they will be short. Apparently the FDA says this is okay if a boy looks as if he is going to be 5′3″ and a girl 4′11″. Why not 5′4″ and 5′? And what is the difference between giving them growth hormone or a super vitamin?

I mean I know the difference, but where is the LINE? I could break my brain on this. You?


advertisement below

7 Responses to “Saturn In Virgo: The Case against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering by Michael J. Sandel”

1.
mudlikesubstance
mudlikesubstance

I suspect in our media saturated world there would be a market for both the super athletes and the “normal guys”

I liken this to the turn-out that the local farm team baseball has. They’re sold out. Every game. The local major league team struggles to sell tickets. Same game. Different take on it.

As to where you draw the line. Well, that depends upon your ethics, your hurdles in your childhood, your weaknesses and your hopes and dreams. Are you asking what the government regulation line is? I’d say that I’m less worried about that then the laws that will come that will exclude so many from health insurance based upon genetic testing. I’m worried about our privacy dropping in direct proportion to the lack of transparency in government.

But then again, it sounds like a fascinating book that I’ll have to get from the library! Thanks for the write up!!

:)

 
2.
Foxxy
Foxxy

I suspect the normal guys would win.

Look at the huge debate over steroids in baseball brought to a head with the homerun record this summer, and the cycling teams in the tour de france refusing to let certain riders go because they were pumped up on various junk. I think we’re coming around to an appreciation for genuine accomplishment. At least I hope we are.

Its an interesting debate though.

 
3.
Amethyst
Amethyst

I think genetic engineering may have a place in the far future, but science would have to completely grok genetics first, and I think we’re a long ways away from that. I know that the scientists right now could maybe turn off this or that right now, but is it really good to meddle with a recipe when one doesn’t really have an understanding of the whole dish?

 
4.
silverfoot
silverfoot

since when has something “not being a good idea” stopped us collectively as a species?

i wonder if genetic engineering will become a bit like plastic surgery? while lots of people nip’n'tuck, and lots of people find that attractive, there are just as many who prefer “real people” with real flaws over the fake, overly cosmeticised people. i think (hope?) there will always be room for the authentic…

 
5.
CD
CD

That sounds like a great book. Our technological breakthroughs are happening so much faster than our ability to process what it all means - plus there are so many tweaks that we take for granted (like the running shoes you mentioned) - although in that case it is something you wear, not like reengineering your actual FOOT or anything…

 
7.
SaDiablo
SaDiablo

In the spirit of “grok” *swoon*, didn’t Heinlen write a book that had this theme?

No, wait. Tanith Lee! Sorry. “The Silver Metal Lover.” It’s a young-adult book, but that doesn’t stop it from being lovely anyway. :)

 


You can also just...


Get A Consultation

Elsa P

I'm available for consultations! You can schedule a consultation by phone or a consultation by email. You can also read what clients have to say about my consultations. Thanks, I look forward to working with you. :)  - Elsa P

 
 

More


 
 
Get this widget!

Recent Blog Comments

  • Lupa: Most definitely. You are the driving force here and it defi...
  • opal: Elsa, this and the Saturn Pluto post are, I think, the most ...
  • lindsey: great song...hope we all find the ace in the dark......
  • grrr: Oaw. THANKS. Words of wisdom. really needed to hear that. ...
  • Ambidee: Great video!...
  • GW: As the soldier would say, “Try not to step on your dick”. ...
  • GW: One of my all time favourite songs....