Commenting On The Comments - Who’s To Say?
Outtakes and Various Other Sundries
Jem left a comment on the last blog… worth reading yourself.
Marc responded with this:
I think its a lesson that the narrative we tell ourselves of what is going on is not the same story others are living by. The same events can be experienced by different people in many different ways. In very real ways we’re all living in remarkably different worlds.
Marc, well said! I reread the post after reading Jem’s comment (and writing my response) and can easily see where she would get the impression she did. It actually reads this way (her way) to me when I use “other people’s eyes, which I did, but distinctly try not to do when I write. Because if I try to think about how people might interpret things it would have a bad effect, like poisoning a well.
And this is the reason I like to present stories in this form anyway. I like to write the dialogue and people can parse it however they want. I know they are going to judge the people involved and this is exactly the point. I want to present a slice of life that is authentic and let people eavesdrop and have their feelings about it whether it’s something stand alone or a story that is unfolding.
So anyway that conversation is real but it is one of many, many, many others. And perhaps if I write more of them a different picture will emerge. I don’t know.
I do know I have been writing (true) dialogue for years now and it is always interesting when someone comes up with something I don’t. Like the day someone said my sister was whiny. Hah!
I reread what I’d written and she was whiny!! But I never saw her that way because she was my BIG sister. You know. She was an icon. So then someone comes along and says, “Man that girl whines a lot” and I was just stunned. But that was a very valuable piece of information.
So anyway, I am just going to keep writing and trying to present things in as pure a form as possible. And people who read here can keep diagnosing! Because I love it.
Thanks Jem and Marc and all the other people who take the time to leave their thoughtful comments on this blog. You are all very much appreciated.

5 Responses to “Commenting On The Comments - Who’s To Say?”
Thanks, Heather. I know this is right and it’s been a perennial problem for me. I don’t like to be repetitive and on the other hand new people come in all the time and it’s hard for me to consider how they might enter this realm.
I try to address this by linking and leaving trails via the tags… or people can search the blog so the information is there if anyone is that interested. But really, I just have to go forward, and be real since this is who I am. There really is no solution to this so I have just to rely on faith… people will get what they get, take what they want and leave the rest.
But it is nice for me to know there are people like you out there who really glean the depth of these relationships that mean so much to me.
I’m with Heather, I’ve got your long-term Big Picture to put each of your snippets in context.
But I know the other side, from my own blogging. Newbies come in all the time, plus some of the old-timers don’t ‘track’ - *at all*!
I was lucky enough to find you at a time when I had a lot of time on my hands and the disclination to do anything else. I read and read and read your blog for days!
I think your solution of peppering meaningful links throughout your blog is best - the rest is up to the readers!
Get A Consultation
I'm available for consultations! You can schedule a consultation by phone or a consultation by email. You can also read what clients have to say about my consultations. Thanks, I look forward to working with you. :) - Elsa P
More
Recent Blog Comments
- von: Leo Uranus opposite Capricorn Moon and Leo Pluto opposite ...
- jo: :) you inspire me....
- GW: Welcome back Elsa. I just lost a friend to cancer two day...
- wyrdling: it was much easier to form healthy relationships (venus) whe...
- ReikiHeart: I'm glad to hear your honeymoon was fulfilling, Elsa. Welcom...
- Dawn: Well the moon in Gemini, the sign of commmunication in combi...
- neva: Got Saturn back exact on my Jupiter/Uranus conjunction -- I ...





I also think time has something to do with it, I’ve been reading your blogs for over 5 years now, and so a lot of the people you write about I feel like I know and I keep the stories in the context that I know them in. I can picture the bar and the pool tables with the soldier dancing with the other girl, I can see Scott holed up in his apartment, again, and you yelling at the door. So sometimes these stories are like clips from a favorite film, if you don’t know the film the clip could have a completely different meaning.
Thanks for continuing to entertain and educate, you are greatly appreciated as well.